Richard B. Belzer
  • Home
  • About
  • Consulting Services
  • Blog
  • Testimony
  • Information Quality
  • Presentations
  • Publications
  • Public Comments
  • Public Comments (Draft)
  • Working Papers
  • Neutral Source
  • Regulatory Checkbook
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Contact
  • Wine Economics
  • Data Repository

Regulatory Impact Analysis for Repeal of Emission Requirements for Glider Vehicles, Glider Engines, and Glider Kits

5/15/2018

0 Comments

 
On April 29, 2018, Fitzgerald Glider Kits LLC hired me to prepare a straw man Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) for an EPA regulation that would repeal certain provisions of a 2016 EPA regulation that would have intentionally driven several companies (including FGK) out of business.

EPA’s 1,116 page RIA for its 2016 regulation includes no incremental analysis of the benefits and costs of these provisions. This omission violated both OMB guidance and EPA guidance, both of which require incremental analysis of key provisions. It is therefore impossible for a third-party to prepare a fully-informed RIA; only a strawman RIA is feasible.

​Nonetheless, the strawman RIA shows that the glider provisions in the 2016 EPA regulation may result in greater greenhouse gas and pollutant emissions. That’s because if gliders are driven off the market as EPA intended in 2016, truck buyers no longer able to buy them are likely to purchase used trucks or retain existing old trucks in service. Used and existing old trucks emit more greenhouse gases and pollutants than gliders. It’s not known how many would purchase new trucks instead of gliders, but because new trucks are 40% more expensive, that fraction is likely to be small.

Meanwhile, the adverse economic effects of the glider provisions in the 2016 EPA regulation are clear — hundreds of millions of dollars in forced early retirement of capital and thousands of American jobs lost. In its RIA, EPA did not acknowledge either of these predictable effects. 

This strawman RIA should be sufficient to justify repealing the glider provisions. EPA has separate authority under the Clean Air Act to regulate rebuilt heavy-duty truck engines if it wants to treat all rebuilt engines fairly instead of discriminating against gliders.

The strawman RIA is #2 on my publications list and is directly accessible here.
0 Comments

Testimony Before the House Science Committee About Improving the Quality of EPA Science

2/5/2012

0 Comments

 
On February 3, I testified before the Subcommittee on Energy and Environment on ways to improve the quality of risk assessment at EPA. My written testimony is here.
0 Comments

    Archives

    May 2018
    November 2013
    April 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    November 2011
    September 2010


    Categories

    All
    Cancer Risk Assessment
    EO 12866
    EPA
    Gliders
    Heavy-Duty Trucks
    Information Quality
    National Toxicology Program
    NTP
    OMB
    Paperwork Reduction Act
    Report On Carcinogens
    Risk Assessment
    USPTO

    RSS Feed

Copyright Richard Burton Belzer 1989-2011 unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved.